What Lenders Won't Tell You: A Butte County Mortgage Q&A

The NorCal Life Real Estate Group • November 22, 2026

We're doing something new this week! Instead of a property tour, we sat down for a Q&A with a local lender. Monica Martinez (DRE#02144565) of The NorCal Life Real Estate Group brought the questions she hears from buyers every week to lender Cameron Elkins (NMLS#1725228), and he gave straight, plain-spoken answers. If you're a first-time buyer in Chico or Butte County sitting on the sidelines, start here.


Should You Wait for Interest Rates to Drop?

Monica's first question was the one on every buyer's mind: interest rates. Cameron's answer is that rates ebb and flow, and the off-season can work in a buyer's favor. Right now buyers can find seller credits and make lower offers. Spring and summer bring more competition and fuller prices. As Cameron puts it, he'd rather buy snow skis in July.

He also warned about the "I'll just wait for rates to go down" plan. Everyone else is waiting too, so when rates drop, buyers go over asking and seller concessions dry up. A buyer who finds a home they love and is comfortable with the payment can look at refinancing later if rates come down.

Waiting has a cost, too. One renter Cameron spoke with had paid around $2,500 to $2,600 a month for almost four years: roughly $110,000 with zero equity. His approach is to run every payment scenario so buyers feel confident and comfortable. The last thing he wants is for someone to be house poor.


Down Payment Assistance for First-Time Buyers

Monica has helped many clients buy with little to no money out of pocket through down payment assistance. Cameron boiled the requirements down to four boxes, going off GSFA and CalHFA guidelines:

  • You're a first-time buyer.
  • You'll live in the home as your primary residence.
  • Your credit score is 640 or higher.
  • Your debt-to-income ratio is at or below 45%. With a score of 700 or higher, that limit rises to 50%.

Each county also has household income limits. Cameron mentioned Butte, Sutter, Colusa, and Glenn counties.

Two details surprised a lot of people. First, you can be a first-time buyer again: if you haven't owned a home or been on a mortgage for 36 months, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac treat you as a first-time buyer. Second, CalHFA's assistance covers the 3% down on a conventional loan, or 3.5% on FHA, as a "silent second." It grows at just 1% simple interest per year, and many families pay it off early with tax refunds.


Do You Really Need 20% Down?

"No, no, no, no, and no." Cameron has helped families get into homes for a couple thousand dollars by pairing down payment assistance with a seller credit that covers most of their closing costs. Waiting to save 20% just to avoid mortgage insurance usually means missing appreciation and paying rent the whole time.


Seller Credits and Rate Buy downs

A seller credit is money the seller leaves on the table so the buyer can cover closing costs. On FHA loans, a buyer can receive up to 6% of the purchase price, and on VA loans up to 4%. Conventional limits are tiered by down payment. A seller credit can also buy down your interest rate, including a 2-1 buydown, where the rate is 2% lower the first year and 1% lower the second.

Why pay $400,000 with a $10,000 seller credit instead of negotiating to $390,000? Cameron explained that the price cut only saves about $70 to $75 a month. The same $10,000 as a credit can keep cash in your bank account, or part of it can buy down your rate, often lowering the payment far more.


Student Loans, Credit, and Self-Employed Buyers

Can you qualify with student loans or a car payment? Absolutely. Most buyers have some debt. Have your credit run early so you get a real game plan. Paying off the wrong account, like your oldest card or an installment loan, can actually lower your score.

Self-employed buyers can buy too. Lenders usually start with two years of tax returns and look at taxable income on your Schedule C, not your gross. If you write off most of your income, a bank statement loan that looks at 12 or 24 months of deposits may be an option.


Is It a Good Time to Buy?

Cameron's answer: yes. Say you rent at $2,000 a month and stay one more year. That's $24,000 in rent. Using 5% appreciation on a $400,000 home as an example, you'd also miss about $20,000 in equity, which makes waiting a $44,000 decision. Compare that with about $12,000 a year if the mortgage payment is $1,000 a month higher than rent. As Cameron put it: the best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago, and the next best time is right now.


Key Takeaways

  1. You don't need 20% down. Down payment assistance plus a seller credit can get some buyers in for a couple thousand dollars.
  2. Down payment assistance has four main boxes: first-time buyer, primary residence, 640+ credit, and debt-to-income at or below 45% (50% with 700+ credit), plus county income limits.
  3. You count as a first-time buyer again after 36 months without owning a home.
  4. A seller credit can cover closing costs or buy down your rate, and it often saves more per month than a small price cut.
  5. Talk to an agent and a lender early. Your credit and debt plan can start long before you're ready to buy.


Have a Question for Our Next Episode?

This is episode one of many. Drop your questions in the YouTube comments, or call The NorCal Life Real Estate Group at (530) 632-9028. You can also contact us here. We'd love to help you plan your path to homeownership in Chico and Butte County.


Cameron Elkins, NMLS#1725228, Guild Mortgage Company, Company NMLS ID 3274. Equal Housing Opportunity. Licensed by the Department of Financial Protection and Innovation under the California Residential Mortgage Lending Act. This video is for educational purposes only and is not a commitment to lend.

Video tour — 5955 Hazel Way, Paradise, CA lot tour, presenter pointing to an aerial view of the lot
By Andrew Haskins • November 14, 2026
Tour 5955 Hazel Way in Paradise — a 0.4-acre lot listed at $34,500 with a new septic tank installed, water and gas run to the property, and an active PID account. Sierra covers the 3 big things to know before buying land in Paradise.
The 1936 Mansion Park home at 346 Mansion Avenue in Chico, California
By Andrew Haskins • November 7, 2026
Tour 346 Mansion Avenue in Chico, CA — a 1936 Mansion Park charmer directly across from Chico State with hardwood floors, a red clawfoot tub, and a large private yard. 3 beds, 2.5 baths, $599,000.
SHOW MORE